We just got back from our first trip to DLRP and stayed in the Sequoia Lodge. It was a decent hotel, though a tiny bit dated. However, we adored the proximity to the Eurostar station, Disney Village, and the parks as we don't drive and don't live near to London or Ashford (adding more travel time...though we still prefer it to flying!).
We're thinking of staying either in the Newport Bay or Hotel New York for our next trip (we decided to splurge for annual passes) as they don't seem significantly more expensive, but are a bit nicer (we walked around all the hotels near to the park while we were there to get an idea!).
We didn't see Santa Fe or Cheyenne and they seemed a bit far (especially as we were there in the winter), though I can see why they would be attractive in the summer months. I'd be curious if anyone thinks the hotels off site are a better deal? I've just joined the Holiday Inn members club (though I can't remember what it's called! lol) so I know I'd get points...I assume that AP members don't get any discount on the off site hotels, but are the shuttles convenient to the parks? Are the facilities significantly different to the Disney hotels or about the same?
Cheers!