DLP Guide Forum - The Disneyland Paris magicforum community

Disneyland Paris => Disneyland Paris Trip Planning => Topic started by: Warner007 on October 19, 2015, 03:43:27 AM

Title: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: Warner007 on October 19, 2015, 03:43:27 AM
 :o
hi guys,
I have two children and girl in yr6 and boy in reception.
im looking at taking them out of school for a trip with myself and husband but also grandparents in march, due to inset day they would only miss two days.
My daughter has perfect attendance, not struggling and always completes her homework etc....
and my son is only in reception.

I never break rules lol so ..... think it will be ok to take them out?
do I call them in sick or notify the school?

we wont be going again and its only time we can go before my daughter is off to secondary school

thansk
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: littlebitofpixiedust on October 19, 2015, 05:50:20 AM
My sons school are quite good but then he does attend a special needs school so that's why I think. Good idea only needing the two days aswell  :) march is generally quiet too so you should get things done.

You could call in sick it's only two days and just say its a bug, not like they can prove otherwise. But on the other hand you could request the time of, although even with good attendance you could be fined. My friends daughter attends my sons special needs school and due to her needs she wouldn't cope on holiday in peak season her school was fine but her two sisters who attend a different school, were denied and my friend was fined. Even though my friend detailed why she was taking them out of school ect.

It's really a personal choice try asking other parents from their schools to get an idea? I think it's disgusting these rules I understand children shouldn't be of for weeks on end ect but I think the old 10day rule was fair or even 5 they should allow, I keep reading they are going to change the rules again fingers crossed. I wouldn't worry to much just book it  ;D and enjoy you only live once !
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: MattR on October 19, 2015, 07:57:24 AM
I would be more worried about the children not telling anybody in school.

When I was a kid, we used to come back one day later a lot of times and one time I was very tired due to our late arrival, fell asleep in class and then told the teacher that we came back from the airport really late yesterday ...
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: daddyof2 on October 19, 2015, 08:55:14 AM
My eldest started full time school this year so we're settling in for 13 years or so of peak time holidays. Yes, it's annoying that prices are higher but it's something we accept. I think you should check the school policy, but regardless of that I doubt you'd be the first parents from the school to take holidays and declare it as sickness
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: Mileto on October 19, 2015, 09:14:13 AM
Oh, these rules! I can't give advise because I'm in another country. Generally it's not good to miss school without a reason.
But we have it here allowed up to three days after a request by the parents. It has to be approved by the director (which he does without problem). So it's easier and not necessary to declare sickness.
This winter we'll have 4 days - so for the 1 day more we should get a special approval.  ::)
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: Zee79 on October 19, 2015, 09:27:50 AM
Check the news recently about the father who challenged the rule & won! :-) we used to do that but not lately, I hate the rule esp since schools can have different term times to each other. My daughters friends have had loads of holidays recently & nothing seems to I have been said yet I know someone asking for one day & refused. You can be off ill for longer & nothing said about missing school. I agree with MattR about the children letting it out though esp your youngest. You could always ask & if refused still take out, it would go down as unauthorised absence on the register.
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: c3po on October 19, 2015, 12:17:48 PM
Wouldn't calling in sick backfire? I imagine the children will return to school and want to tell their friends and teachers all about their time at DLP.
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: rebecca20 on October 19, 2015, 01:29:23 PM
In terms of getting a fixed penalty notice the rules have recently changed and so you need to check with your local authority as to how many sessions a child can miss prior to getting the fine e.g. 4 sessions is two days worth of school.

That's the only way to legally make sure. I highly doubt that they would prosecute you for such a small absence but I obviously can't say this for sure, normally it is a repeated pattern over a term before the local authority really investigate.

My Dad works for a local authority prosecuting and working with families in relation to this so I know the process the local authority have to take prior to prosecution.

If you want anymore info let me know. The reason everyone could be having trouble is because of the recent changes to the law and it not being a national law but delegated to each council and then to sub-teams within.
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: grovesie on October 19, 2015, 02:18:11 PM
I wonder how the recent ruling ( Parent gets fine reversed) will change things? see news link below

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/educationnews/11937117/Parent-wins-term-time-fine-victory-after-taking-daughter-to-Disney-World.html
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: rebecca20 on October 19, 2015, 02:29:16 PM
Unfortunately as it is only a Magistrates Court ruling it does nothing legally. Only if someone appeals will there be a precedent set.
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: HildeKitten on October 19, 2015, 04:16:04 PM
I'm not in the UK so I couldn't say, but surely if your daughter has perfect attendance and good grades, and it doesn't actually matter loads for your son as it is, I can't see why you would get in trouble.
Surely those fines are there for problem cases, not people who are normally always in order.

Can you not, as parents, take your children out of school for "familial reasons"?
Here in Belgium children can be absent for 3 days (although apparently no longer three days in a row without the principal's consent) per school year like that, so maybe see if there is something similar for the UK?
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: seraphelle on October 19, 2015, 06:19:54 PM
I'm having this internal debate myself at the moment. My two would be missing 3 days of school, and I was initially going to phone them in sick on the first day but I know full well when they're back at school with their friends they won't be able to keep a trip to DLP to themselves  ;D
I've heard that the Head at our school was granting time off up to 5 days, but nothing more than that was allowed. With this recent case in the news, there is at least some scope for defending against any fines. I think I may chance it and fill in a leave request form. If I get fined I may just raise holy hell as my two have perfect attendance aside from this.
From what I can see on my local authority webpages only absences greater than 5 days are 'cause for concern' so I would have thought a lot of LA's were using this figure as a benchmark.
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: stifle on October 19, 2015, 06:40:59 PM
Quote from: HildeKitten on October 19, 2015, 04:16:04 PM
I'm not in the UK so I couldn't say, but surely if your daughter has perfect attendance and good grades, and it doesn't actually matter loads for your son as it is, I can't see why you would get in trouble.
Surely those fines are there for problem cases, not people who are normally always in order.

Can you not, as parents, take your children out of school for "familial reasons"?
Here in Belgium children can be absent for 3 days (although apparently no longer three days in a row without the principal's consent) per school year like that, so maybe see if there is something similar for the UK?

The law in the UK was made much more strict a few years ago and it is now a £60 fine for missing even a day without consent. Some schools will apply discretion but the government will penalise them for not dealing with poor attendance (by cutting their budgets or even firing the head teacher) so many schools say their hands are tied.
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: grovesie on October 20, 2015, 09:39:53 AM
As previously stated the fines are normally issued for persistent offenders and those with bad attendance records. We have often taken our children out of school for a few days, the saving more than makes up for the fines, and we have never had a fine yet...... We ensure that any missed course work is completed.

There would not be this problem if the travel companies did not make the prices so high when the schools close. I am also in the opinion that the school should be able to use a bit of common sense and agree leave for students that have better attendance records.

When I ask my kids what they have done in class towards the end of a term my youngest normally replies watch a film or played games. How is this any different to going away?
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: Warner007 on October 20, 2015, 10:09:07 AM
Thanks guys,
I'm going to request it if they decline, tuff lol

Exactly quality family time far more important than playing games & watching films!
We do that at home thanks.

X
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: lovindisney87 on October 20, 2015, 10:37:33 AM
I am taking my two out of school for our holiday in January, to be honest both of mine have great attendance, never late complete homework etc so I cant see that a few days off will really affect them, they are both working ahead of there age group and I am more than willing to have any work they may miss caught up with at home if needs be. I am expecting a fine to be honest but I will be requesting the time off with a letter explaining about attendance and being happy for them to catch up at home ect etc. My oldest has just started high school so am not sure what's going to happen there. I wouldnt take them out when I knew they had exams etc coming up.
I signed a petition online about allowing parents to take them out of school for 2 weeks of the year and it is scheduled to be debated in parliament on the 26th of this month, hopefully they will see sense and if a child does have great attendance and are doing well they could give you a bit of a break.
We have people at our school who are continuously late every day and they get nothing so why penalise people who get there children to school regularly 😒
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: Warner007 on October 20, 2015, 10:40:51 AM
Couldn't agree more lovingdisney87!!!!!!!
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: chopbop on October 20, 2015, 10:46:51 AM
I agree im taking my daughter end of November beginning December shes got good attendance looking forward to it ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: lovindisney87 on October 20, 2015, 10:50:15 AM
Quote from: Warner007 on October 20, 2015, 10:40:51 AM
Couldn't agree more lovingdisney87!!!!!!!

👍😁
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: rebecca20 on October 20, 2015, 01:34:16 PM
To be honest I can see both sides - but as I say it's down to the Local Authority NOT the school to decide when a fine should be imposed. You have to remember that most places do allow up to two days absence and the most generous is a week!

Saying that I would probably take my child out and just pay the £60 fine. You definitely won't end up with anymore serious action being pursued providing you pay within 28 days.
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: Mintcar on October 20, 2015, 08:22:13 PM
 :-X  Don't even get me started on this subject......

Ever since my first son (now 13yrs) was 9 months old, we have taken him on holiday once or twice a year.  Sometimes that has been a week tagged on May half term - when the rules were more relaxed.  Sometimes it was a couple of days tagged onto the main holiday periods.  Sometimes it has been for a weekend away at Center Parcs. 

I understand how the ruling is imposed to safeguard children, however that does seem at the expense of some.  My child, is just that - my child.  If I deem that they will benefit more from going on a holiday when I can afford it by jiggling a day here and there, then for goodness sake of course I'm going to do it!  I've even used the 'sick card' before with the eldest.  But never for more than one or two days.

As a result of taking my children abroad they understand a great deal of the World around them.  They also see Mum & Dad without the everyday cares and worries that can dull the edges of life.  We get to laugh, swim, play experience and enjoy each other in a relaxed environment.

My kids have are making good progress, have excellent attendance and I will apologise to no-one for the decisions I make on this subject.  Much less pay a fine!

I know it is sooo difficult for the school/headteachers.  Our headteacher has been particularly understanding over recent years as we live in Cornwall and some parents simply cannot take off time during peak holiday periods.

If you are not abusing the system and 'repeat' offending at every available opportunity - then I believe as human beings we have the right to enjoy special time with our children.  Life is short and often stolen away without warning.  Memories are the most treasured gift we can have.

So, if I were you, I'd do it!

Sorry, I'll shut up now  :-[

Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: littlebitofpixiedust on October 20, 2015, 10:30:40 PM
I agree with the above posts  ;)

Life is to short I have two friends who lost their children aged 5 and the other child 6. I am very close with one of the mums still and she talks often about their trip to DLP and relieves all the fun and enjoyment they had. Where my son is disabled obviously many of my friends have disabled children also and since having my son it's taught me so much especially that time and memories are precious.

People need to still have a life outside of work and I believe same with children too! I'm not saying kids should have lots of holidays ect but surely a week a year or even a few days?

Our children grow up fast as do us parents! And I say enjoy it while we can while our kids still want to be kids and become independent and working themselves and worrying about the things we do! I hope the law changes because it will benefit so many families especially those that simply cannot afford to go in school holidays ect it really isn't fair.

I personally would request the time off If your fined, your fined. Still will be worth it  ;D
Title: Re: EEEK taking kids out of school
Post by: abismummy on October 21, 2015, 10:30:41 PM
The official line is to refer to the courts if 10 consecutive sessions (5 days) are missed or if attendance is below 85%. Just fill in a holiday request form - this will probably not get authorised but at least you are telling them where the children are and there is nothing further they can do about it.
If I didn't work in a school I would do this. Have a great holiday! x